Article

Rankings have far-reaching implications

Letter addresses 2010 Ophthalmology Times Best Programs survey.

I recently received an invitation to participate in a survey intended to gain enough information to rank residency programs as part of the 2010 Ophthalmology Times Best Programs survey (See Oct. 1, 2010 issue). This is a very worthwhile undertaking, but I am concerned about the validity of the outcome.

Certainly this information would be very useful to many interested parties. Applicants from medical school would have a roadmap to help them navigate through the often-confusing residency maze. Industry might invest in those programs that are ranked highly to bring greater credibility to their clinical trials. Patients willing to travel might seek second opinions based on where the published quality of care is better. Even the programs themselves undoubtedly would use this information in their marketing as evidenced by billboard ads in Cincinnati quoting the results of the U.S. News and World Reports survey. In other words, the published outcomes ranking residencies will have far-reaching implications.

Ophthalmology Times must take this task very seriously and be willing to develop a methodology that will recover accurate information leading to valid results. This means that the voting should not be either a popularity contest or an opportunity to pay homage to the program where the voter trained. Objective measures, such as the performance on the boards or the number of cataract surgeries performed, would be useful examples. It would be helpful to stratify program strengths. For example, which programs are stronger in retina or research? It would be interesting to know which programs have fellows competing with residents for the surgical volume available. And what percentage of graduating residents continue their own education with a fellowship?

The seven members of our retina team host an evening fluorescein conference that the residents just love. Moreover, I encourage the residents to schedule cases where I can assist them and I look forward to buying them dinner on Tuesday evenings for a quarterly 3-D video conference. Our chairman, James Augsburger, MD, insists that resident education is as important a priority as anything. How is this type of commitment going to be measured?

I applaud the ambitious task that Ophthalmology Times has initiated, but it is going to take a thoughtful and well-conceived game plan to produce meaningful results. I urge you to take this initiative very seriously and establish a team of residency directors to help define the criteria upon which the voting is based.

Robert H. Osher, MDProfessor of OphthalmologyUniversity of Cincinnati College of MedicineMedical Director EmeritusCincinnati Eye Institute, Cincinnati, OH

Letters to the Editor may be submitted to mdlugoss@advanstar.com
Letters may be edited for clarity and length.

Newsletter

Don’t miss out—get Ophthalmology Times updates on the latest clinical advancements and expert interviews, straight to your inbox.

Related Videos
Lisa Nijm, MD, says preoperative osmolarity testing can manage patient expectations and improve surgical results at the 2025 ASCRS annual meeting
At the 2025 ASCRS Annual Meeting, Weijie Violet Lin, MD, ABO, shares highlights from a 5-year review of cross-linking complications
Maanasa Indaram, MD, is the medical director of the pediatric ophthalmology and adult strabismus division at University of California San Francisco, and spoke about corneal crosslinking (CXL) at the 2025 ASCRS annual meeting
(Image credit: Ophthalmology Times) ASCRS 2025: Taylor Strange, DO, assesses early visual outcomes with femto-created arcuate incisions in premium IOL cases
(Image credit: Ophthalmology Times) ASCRS 2025: Neda Shamie, MD, shares her early clinical experience with the Unity VCS system
Patricia Buehler, MD, MPH, founder and CEO of Osheru, talks about the Ziplyft device for noninvasive blepharoplasty at the 2025 American Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgeons (ASCRS) annual meeting
(Image credit: Ophthalmology Times) ASCRS 2025: Bonnie An Henderson, MD, on leveraging artificial intelligence in cataract refractive surgery
(Image credit: Ophthalmology Times) ASCRS 2025: Gregory Moloney, FRANZO, FRCSC, on rotational stability
Sheng Lim, MD, FRCOphth, discusses the CONCEPT study, which compared standalone cataract surgery to cataract surgery with ECP, at the 2025 ASCRS Annual Meeting.
(Image credit: Ophthalmology Times) ASCRS 2025: Steven J. Dell, MD, reports 24-month outcomes for shape-changing IOL
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.